← All States

Illinois

High tax burden · COL index 92

Wins 7 categories

VS

Idaho

Moderate tax burden · COL index 96

Wins 8 categories

Property taxes are meaningfully different: Illinois averages 1.73% annually vs Idaho's 0.48%. The median home in Idaho costs $425K vs $275K in Illinois. Politically, Idaho voted Republican in 2024 (R+30.0) while Illinois went Democratic (D+14.0).

Illinois
Idaho

Taxes

4.95%
Income Tax (top rate)
5.8%
1.73%/yr
Property Tax Rate
0.48%/yr
8.82%
Sales Tax (avg)
6.02%
Yes
Social Security Tax
Yes
No
Estate Tax
Yes
As income
Capital Gains Tax
As income

Housing & Cost of Living

92
COL Index (100=avg)
96
$275K
Median Home Price
$425K
$1,400/mo
Median Rent (2BR/mo)
$1,500/mo
$2K/yr
Home Insurance (avg/yr)
$800/yr

Crime & Safety

413
Violent Crime / 100K
228
1,666
Property Crime / 100K
1,535

Healthcare

#20 of 50
Healthcare Quality Rank
#32 of 50
77.2 yrs
Life Expectancy
77.7 yrs
7.4%
Uninsured Rate
9%
Yes
Medicaid Expansion
Yes

Education

#16 of 50
K-12 Quality Rank
#30 of 50
No
School Choice / Vouchers
No

Childcare

$1,650/mo
Avg Infant Care / mo
$960/mo

Utilities & Daily Costs

$145/mo
Avg Energy Bill / mo
$105/mo
$510/mo
Avg Groceries / mo
$480/mo
#40 of 50
Road Quality Rank
#20 of 50

Social Policy

A
Gun Laws Grade
F
D+14.0
2024 Presidential Margin
R+30.0

Category wins

7

Illinois

8

Idaho

Run the full slider tool to score these states against your specific income, home value, retirement, and lifestyle priorities.

Score For My Profile →

People Also Ask

What are the drawbacks of living in Idaho?

Is Illinois the best state to live in?

Why are people moving out of Idaho?

What do I need to know before moving to Idaho?

Full Illinois Profile →Full Idaho Profile →

Your Priorities

Adjust and every page updates live

Quick Profiles

Dial in your priorities

Annual Income

$150K

Affects effective income tax rate

$0$500K$5M+

Retirement Savings

$0

Affects pension and SS tax burden

None$500K$10M+

Social Security

None

Annual Social Security benefit

None$150K/yr

My Property Is Worth

$400K

Affects property tax burden

Tax burden ↓$1M$50M+

Home Buying Budget

$400K

Compared to state median home price

Hard to find$250K$5M+

Monthly Rent Budget

Don't care

Compared to state median 2BR rent

Don't care$10K/mo

Job Market

Don't care

State unemployment and job growth

Don't careHot market

Airport Access

Don't care

Direct flight destinations from state hubs

Don't careMust have hub

City vs Country

Mid-size city

% urban population

Deep countryBig city

Sunshine

Don't care

Annual sunny days per state

Don't careMax sunshine

Food Scene

Don't care

Restaurants per 100K residents

Don't careWorld-class

Political Preference

Neutral

State's political lean

LiberalConservative

Gun Laws

Neutral

State gun law grade (Giffords)

Gun Control2A Freedom

Abortion Access

Neutral

State abortion access policy

Pro-ChoiceNeutralPro-Life

Community

None

Congregations per 100K residents

AvoidDon't careSeek

Sports & Entertainment

Don't care

Pro sports teams and major venues

Don't careMust have pro teams

Cannabis Laws

Neutral

State cannabis legality

Prefer LegalNeutralPrefer Prohibition

Retiree Community

Neutral

% population 65+ (Census)

Young areaRetirement-heavy

Dating Market

Neutral

% adults never-married (Census)

Singles sceneFamily community

Safety / Low Crime

Don't care

Violent crime rate per 100K (FBI)

Don't careVery safe

School Quality

Don't care

K-12 rank (Education Week)

Don't careTop-ranked

Healthcare Access

Don't care

Healthcare system rank (Commonwealth Fund)

Don't careTop-ranked

Childcare Affordability

Don't care

Cost of living proxy for childcare affordability

Don't careMust be affordable